Brendan Lally wrote: > Gameplay is to me the key point, If there is drowning, then there is > no need to have massive alterations to world maps that have open > bodies of water (and illogical limits on where a player can and can't > swim). If some characters are not guarenteed to be able to drown, then > they could go anywhere in a body of water, which would mean a need to > modify them to define where someone can't swim to. > Your right here - it's all about gameplay. While I like the idea (an elegant solution to the problem) I'm simply exploring the holes/complaints I think players/people might try to poke in it. > The 'all water is partially holy water' argument does have one other > problem, in that wraiths can drink potions of water with no ill > effects. Indeed - and being rained on if the weather code is used or drinking standard water bottles. That being said it's certainly still a viable option. > >> Isn't holy water blessed by a priest to become holy, and after it's been >> used no longer "holy" and just "water"? In this case wouldn't water >> returned to the sea no longer be holy? > > > That's an interesting question, I infer from the wikipedia quote > above, that the water would then no longer be exorcised, but that is > an unsourced line from a wikipedia article. I have been unable to find > a better reference myself. > > I do know that the quantity of water recognised as holy by any person > is a tiny fraction of the world's total (even if the hindu > intrepretation is used where (as I understand it) the entire river > gagnes is considered holy - I'm unsure on this point, and would > welcome it being corrected, I don't think hinduism has exorcism of > water in the same way as Christianity.) > > Anyway, regardless of the reality of holy water, the world of > crossfire is polytheistic, one god can define its persistance in > rivers, seas and streams (but not in glass bottles, or fountains - > sounds kinda like a gaea sort of claim to me.), while the others > don't. > > If their banishments can work against wraith, why not their holy water? Works for me! > > _______________________________________________ > crossfire mailing list > crossfire at metalforge.org > http://mailman.metalforge.org/mailman/listinfo/crossfire > > > -- Joshua Wilson www.woosworld.net