Just a reminder:

There are probably at least some people on this list for whom the
technical quality of the solution is NOT the only determiner, as your
post suggests.

There are people who have deep ideological commitments to Free
Software (Free as in Speech), that are not limited to trying to find
one's boss the best widget.

I am not going to comment on the rightness or wrongness of this, but
if one wants to discuss this issue seriously, one should take into
account all the factors.

R